home email sign-up search
HealthCast Calendar
Daily Reports Health Poll Search
Issue Spotlight
Daily Reports
Daily Health Policy Report
Daily HIV/AIDS Report
Weekly Health Disparities Report
First Edition
Search All Daily Reports Archives
 

Site Search

 

 

 



Kaiser Daily Women's Health Policy
  • Printer-Friendly Page
  • Email this Page
  • Share
  • Reprint
In The Courts | Federal Judge Rules Union Pacific Discriminated Against Female Employees by Barring Contraceptive Coverage
[Jul 27, 2005]

      U.S. District Judge Laurie Smith Camp in Omaha, Neb., on Friday ruled that Union Pacific Railroad -- which employs about 49,000 workers nationwide, including 1,300 women -- illegally discriminated against female employees by not providing contraceptive coverage in its health plans, the Los Angeles Times reports. Although Smith Camp did not order the company to begin covering contraceptives, she said Union Pacific's policy violated the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits employers with 15 or more employees from discrimination based on gender or pregnancy. The class-action lawsuit -- which was filed by two female Union Pacific employees, who were represented by Planned Parenthood of Western Washington -- sought to require the company to provide coverage for FDA-approved prescription contraceptives for women employees and the female family members of male employees covered by the company's policies (Selvin, Los Angeles Times, 7/26). Smith Camp ruled that the health plan policy was discriminatory because it covered many preventive health medications -- including drugs for erectile dysfunction -- but not contraception (O'Hanlon, AP/Yahoo! News, 7/25). The company argued that it did not need to provide contraceptive coverage "because fertility is 'normal'" therefore birth control is not "medically necessary." In her ruling, Smith Camp acknowledged that fertility is normal but added, "There is also no doubt that pregnancy is a condition that has a profound impact on a woman's health." Later rulings will determine what Union Pacific must change about its current policies in order to comply with the Civil Rights Act (Los Angeles Times, 7/26). Union Pacific spokesperson Mark Davis said the company likely will appeal the ruling (AP/Yahoo! News, 7/25). Davis said the company's union during its most recent labor agreement agreed to not provide contraceptives in its negotiated health care plan (Sorid, Reuters, 7/25).

For current women's health policy news, visit the National Partnership for Women & Families' website.


...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... .....



About Us     Help